Shark Jumping 101: The TV Problem

I spend a lot of time on this blog talking about television but since I started this blog as an outlet while working at a TV station, I feel that the constant discussion of television and movies is warranted. My wife and I have spent a lot of time this week talking about television and what passes for good TV these days. Actually, we have spent quite a few months talking about it, even dedicating a few episodes of our weekly movie podcast to discussion of our favorite shows and what works about them. Good television is source of comfort and bad television only serves to annoy viewers eventually. It's a complicated process to make a television show in the 21st century, particularly with the changing of the guard from linear broadcast TV to on-demand services and the binge watching that will largely be the television consumption of the future. Furthermore, one has to decide if the show they are working on is a piece of art or if the ratings and dollar are king. All of this is compounded by the fact that for at least the last 10 years or so, we have seen a renewed interest in Television as a medium - a golden age for new shows and for actors to do something different.

With shows like Breaking Bad, Shameless, and The Sopranos as glowing examples, it's easy to see how television has really become a force to contend with over the last decade. Many actors strive to have their own television show that is both groundbreaking and successful and there are so many great shows out there to see, that it becomes difficult to keep up with all of them. However, this influx of new shows has a downside as well: over-saturation. For every successful show there are several that fall by the wayside, some deserving to and others cut short before they can even reach their prime. This is made glaringly obvious when you consider what shows get cancelled and what gets to continue ruining television. Here is a great list of all the things that are being renewed alongside all those that have either been cancelled or are not being renewed for the next year , notably 2 Broke Girls, Castle, Last Man Standing and Scream Queens. Meanwhile, the bloated and extremely unfunny Big Bang Theory continues to get renewed season after season. I'm not really a fan of any of the shows that I named but I do know that they have their own following and that it doesn't seem fair that the aforementioned bloated nightmare gets to continue while these get cancelled. I can say from experience and the data serves to prove that ratings matter and that TV is less about art than it is about money. Such is the way of life.

What bothers me about television is a two fold problem. First, with the advent of Netflix and the success that they have seen with original shows being produced for them, is there as much pressure to hit a ratings cap, sacrificing the artistic value of your show? I think that shows like Master of None or Orange is the New Black are great examples of shows not feeling pressure to sacrifice their vision in the pursuit of money because the monetization for those shows works differently. They aren't tied to ad revenue and therefore aren't subject to interference in production. Furthermore, with the Netflix model, every show gets a full season and a chance to shine. If it doesn't work out, they just simply don't produce a second season but there are not any "Firefly" situations with the Netflix model which is great. This is the way that TV will be consumed in the future and it makes me very happy to see shows be a little more brave because they don't have to chase advertising dollars.

Second, and probably the most prominent topic of conversation in our household, is the problem of the shows that don't know when to stop. Screen Rant did a great list of shows that need to end immediately which you find here and I think I agree with all of them, even 2 Broke Girls which I referenced earlier and it seems that the network agreed on that.  I was having a conversation with my mother in law today about Supernatural and it seems that many fans disagree on the sustainability of that show.  Personally I stopped watching in the culminating episode of season 5 because up to that point, with the exception of some poorly written lines here and there, the show was pretty much perfect. There was an ambitious and creative story with well thought out development and nothing really seemed out of place or too overdone and yet, after the finale of that season, the creators got the opportunity to renew and jumped at the chance. This didn't seem like a bad idea at the time but now, as the show is set to enter its thirteenth season, I wish it had ended then. My wife enjoyed the show for much longer and only recently has her disillusionment with it begun to grow. Several of our friends still enjoy while many think it should have died awhile back, bringing me to question what really is the "jumping the shark" moment for any particular show today? The Simpsons has been on for 28 seasons and I can't say I know anyone that regularly watches it. And for that matter, who the hell is watching the Big Bang Theory? Please stop! And if you insist that it's still funny, just read this.

It's hard not to be disillusioned with television and the industry when good shows get the ax and shows that should have ended still get to air but that's just they way things are and the way they have been for many years. Back to my conversation with my mother in law: she pointed out that perhaps my expectations are far too high for television, making the point that I shouldn't be looking for intelligence from that medium and I think that's more than true at this point. Television is just another form of entertainment that we consume and pay for and at the end of the day, if a show isn't perfect, it doesn't have much influence on my life anyway.

In summation, I need better things to complain about. Maybe next week I can trash books and authors.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Advantages and Disadvantages of Convenience: The Sudden Implosion of the Brick and Mortar Entertainment Experience

Catharsis at the Tourist Trap. Thoughts on a Year of Marraige

Goodbye 2016: Resolutions and Perspectives